Benable — create shareable lists of things you recommend!
E.g., products you love, local businesses, travel recs - you can add anything to a Benable list!
Cookie Cutters That Tricked My Picky Eater Into Loving Lunch
30
items When your kid picks apart every sandwich and only eats plain bread, lunchtime feels like a hostage negotiation. I was running out of ideas until I started cutting food into shapes — dinosaurs, stars, hearts — and suddenly my three-year-old was eating...
Sections
10
Sandwich Cookie Cutter Sets
Mini Cookie Cutters for Fruits and Veggies
Bento Lunchbox Containers
Fun Sandwich Picks and Food Picks
Silicone Bento Cups and Dividers
Kid-Friendly Bread for Shaped Sandwiches
Sandwich Cookie Cutter Sets
The whole reason my kid eats sandwiches now instead of deconstructing them like a crime scene. These sets have enough variety that lunch doesn't get boring after a week.
Grab this massive set and you'll never run out of shapes — I rotate through dinosaurs, stars, and trucks so my son thinks every lunch is a surprise. Worth it for anyone whose kid rejects anything that looks like a normal sandwich.
Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece — Alphabet
Use these if your toddler won't touch crusts — they cut and seal the edges so nothing falls apart in the lunchbox. Before these, I was peeling crusts off like a surgeon every morning.
Lunch Punch Sandwich Cutters - Bento Pairs
Snag this for the dinosaur and vehicle shapes specifically — my nephew went from refusing ham sandwiches to requesting ‘dino ham’ daily. Perfect for the 2-5 age range where everything needs to be fun or it's a hard no.
Yettn 5-Piece Plastic Cookie Cutter Set
Mini Cookie Cutters for Fruits and Veggies
Cutting cucumbers into stars sounds ridiculous until your kid eats an entire cucumber in one sitting. That actually happened at my house.
Keep these in your drawer for quick fruit and veggie cuts — watermelon stars disappear off the plate in seconds. Before I had these, my daughter wouldn't touch melon unless it was in a pouch.
Ateco 7808 Plain Edge Star Cutter Set in Graduated Sizes
Try the tiny shapes on cheese slices and deli meat too — my kids started calling them ‘cheese stars’ and now they ask for them. Sized right for anyone dealing with toddler portions.
Wilton Cookie Cutters Set, 101-Piece — Alphabet
Pair these with cucumber rounds and suddenly your veggie-refusing kid is eating ‘flower cucumbers’ without complaint. Took me two years of begging before I figured out the shape trick.
R&M International Christmas Mini Cookie Cutter 6 Piece Set
Bento Lunchbox Containers
No point making cute shaped food if it arrives at school looking like abstract art. These keep everything in its own little compartment so the shapes stay intact.
Switch to this if your kid's lunch keeps getting smashed — the five compartments mean the dinosaur sandwich stays a dinosaur. My son's teacher actually complimented his lunches now, which never happened before.
Customer reviews for Bentgo Kids Lunch Bag
Use this for the adult version when you inevitably start making yourself star sandwiches too — no shame, I do it. Keeps dressing separate so nothing gets soggy by noon.
Bentgo Fresh, Leak-Proof
Toss this in your cart if you need something budget-friendly that still keeps food separated — clips shut tight and survived my kid dropping it off the counter twice.
Sistema To Go Collection Bento Box Cube 5.3 Cup
Fun Sandwich Picks and Food Picks
Shaped food is step one. Sticking a little sword pick through it is step two. My kid went from suspicious to excited the day I added these.
Ditch the plain toothpicks and try these animal picks — my daughter eats fruit she normally ignores just because there's a tiny bear holding it. Sounds absurd but it works every single time.
Kids Food Picks 20 Pack, Cute Animal Toothpicks for Bento
Grab a big pack so you're not washing four picks every night — these are colorful enough that my kids fight over who gets the green one. Great for anyone packing lunches five days a week.
20-Piece Kids Animal Fruit Forks, Cute Toddler Food Picks
Bring these out when your kid has a rough morning and needs a lunchbox mood boost — the little flag shapes make even crackers feel special. Wish I'd found these during the pandemic lunch struggles.
Torune 8 Piece Bento Decoration Food Picks Forks Cute
Silicone Bento Cups and Dividers
Without these, the applesauce migrates into the crackers and your kid acts like you've personally betrayed them. Ask me how I know.
Keep wet and dry foods apart with these — they fit perfectly inside most lunchboxes and my kids haven't complained about soggy crackers since I started using them. Dishwasher safe too, which matters when you're exhausted.
Bentgo, Bento Lunch Box
Use these as makeshift bento dividers — they're cheaper than the branded ones and work just as well. For the parent who's already spent too much money on lunch accessories this month.
Cupcake Baking Cups 10 Pack
Toss hummus or ranch in these so your kid can dip without making a disaster — before I did this, every lunchbox came home looking like a crime scene. Stock up because they roll under the dishwasher rack constantly.
Pantry Elements Silicone Cupcake Liners
Kid-Friendly Bread for Shaped Sandwiches
Not all bread holds its shape when you punch a cookie cutter through it. I ruined a lot of slices before figuring out which ones actually work.
Try this soft white bread for clean cookie cutter shapes — it doesn't crumble or tear like some whole wheat breads do. Took me three brands to land on this one after too many mangled dinosaurs.
Nature's Own Butterbread Bread, 20 oz
Swap to this thicker bread when you want shapes that hold up with heavier fillings like peanut butter — the slices are wide enough that you don't lose half the shape to the crust. My go-to for PB&J stars.
Sara Lee® Artesano™ Golden Wheat Bread
Grab this when Artesano is sold out — slightly denser so the shapes hold their edges really well. Anyone making shaped sandwiches in bulk for a birthday party needs bread this sturdy.
Pepperidge Farm Farmhouse Hearty White Bread, 24 oz Loaf
Spreaders and Kid-Safe Knives
My five-year-old wanted to help make her own star sandwiches, so I needed tools she could use without me hovering like a helicopter.
Get these for the kid who wants to spread their own peanut butter — they actually cut soft foods but won't cut fingers. My daughter feels like a real chef and I stopped holding my breath every time she's in the kitchen.
Curious Chef, Nylon Knife Set, 3-Piece, Safe for Kids
Pair this with the cookie cutters and let your kid press out their own shapes — mine started eating more when she made lunch herself. Works for ages 4 and up without being flimsy.
Tovla Jr. Kids Kitchen Knife and Foldable Cutting Board
Use this for even peanut butter layers so the cookie cutter glides through clean — lumpy spread equals torn bread equals toddler meltdown. Learned that equation the hard way about forty times.
Nylon Sandwich Spreader, White
Reusable Snack Bags for Shaped Foods
Ziploc bags crush the shapes you just spent five minutes making. These keep everything protected and you're not throwing away plastic every day.
Switch to these from plastic bags and your star sandwiches actually survive the backpack ride — they're rigid enough to protect shapes. Paying for itself after about three weeks of not buying disposables.
Stasher Reusable Silicone Storage Bag, 3 Pack
Toss crackers and cheese shapes in these — they lay flat so nothing gets crushed and they're machine washable. For the parent who's tired of finding crumpled Ziplocs in every coat pocket.
Bumkins Reusable Snack Bag, Small, Sea Friends
Grab the larger size for full sandwiches — the wide opening means you can slide a dinosaur sandwich in without decapitating it. Sounds dramatic but you'll understand the first time a head falls off.
Russbe Reusable Snack Bags for Home Use
Sprinkles and Edible Decorations
Sometimes the shape alone isn't enough and you need to bribe them with rainbow sprinkles on cream cheese. No judgment here — results matter.
Toss a few of these on a cream cheese star sandwich and watch your picky eater lose their mind with excitement — my son calls it ‘party lunch’ and eats every bite. Zero nutritional value, maximum cooperation.
WILTON JIMMIES RAINBOW SHORT 6 CELL 72g
Keep a bottle in the pantry for emergency lunch negotiations — when nothing else works, sprinkles on buttered bread shaped like a heart gets the job done. For desperate Tuesdays specifically.
Betty Crocker Rainbow Sprinkles - 1.75 oz
Pair star-shaped decors on star-shaped sandwiches and your toddler thinks you're a wizard — the meta-ness of it somehow works. Wish someone had told me food decoration psychology was a parenting skill I'd need.
Moon, Stars and Clouds Silicone Mold
Cookie Cutter Storage and Organization
Dumping 50 metal cutters into a drawer means you'll stab yourself reaching for a spatula at 6 AM. Found that out firsthand.
Snap all your mini cutters into one of these and toss it in a drawer — no more rummaging through a pile of sharp metal shapes half-asleep. Costs almost nothing and saved my fingertips.
CLEAR
Use a bigger one of these for the full-size cutter collection — I sorted mine by category so I can grab ‘dinosaur week’ or ‘holiday shapes’ without digging. For anyone whose kitchen drawer has become a cookie cutter graveyard.
Mainstays 28 Qt Underbed Plastic Storage Bins with Lids
Stick a few of these inside a cabinet door and hang your most-used cutters right where you can see them — morning lunch prep went from five minutes of searching to five seconds of grabbing. Should have done this a year ago.
3M Command Large Wall Hooks, holds 2kg