I wanted a firmer, more supportive feel without buying a new mattress, so I rounded up toppers, pillows and wedges that all come in under $100. Toppers are listed in queen unless noted, and the smaller sizes cost less. (Note: This list contains affil...
Linenspa's gel topper softened the hard feel of my old mattress and sleeps cooler than plain foam I have tried. It arrives rolled, so give it a day to expand. Start here if your bed feels too firm at the shoulders and hips.
Linenspa 3 Inch Gel Memory Foam Topper
Lucid's lavender-infused foam has a faint, calming scent and a plush feel that my side-sleeping shoulders appreciate. It fits under a regular fitted sheet. Go for this if you want a softer bed without buying a new mattress.
Lucid 3 Inch Lavender Memory Foam Topper
Adding cushion without making the bed feel like quicksand is where the ZINUS green tea topper shines. It has a light, fresh scent out of the box. Pick it if you want a subtle upgrade that keeps the support of your mattress.
ZINUS 3 Inch Green Tea Memory Foam Topper
This gel topper comes with a zip cover I can wash, and the foam springs back quickly each morning. It feels medium firm rather than mushy. Worth it if you want a topper that stays in place and is easy to keep clean.
Ultra Responsive Gel Mattress Topper
Ballad's ventilated gel foam breathes better than older toppers I have owned, and the corner straps keep it from sliding. It suits most sleeping positions. Grab this if your current topper always shifts overnight.
Ballad 3 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper Queen
Novilla's topper feels supportive rather than soft, so my hips do not sink too far in. It is a budget pick that still feels substantial. Pick this if you want a firmer-feeling topper without spending much.
Novilla Queen Memory Foam Mattress Topper 3 Inch ...
This dual layer topper pairs memory foam with a quilted fiber top, so it feels plush and contouring at once. It smoothed out the dips in my guest bed. Worth it if your mattress feels uneven and a bit tired.
Sleep Innovations Dual Layer 4 Inch Memory Foam
The Bedsure pillow top has a quilted, plush fill and a deep pocket skirt that fits like a fitted sheet. It is waterproof, so spills are less stressful. Go for this if you want soft comfort and easy washing.
Bedsure Pillow Top Mattress Topper Queen Waterproof
Mine arrived compressed, and the Milemont topper puffed up within a day, giving my bed a thicker, hotel-style feel. It is easy to spot clean. Pick it if you want a plush topper without a big spend.
Milemont Mattress Topper
The Coop Eden pillow lets me remove or add fill until the height feels right for my sleeping position. The cover feels soft and cool. Worth it if no pillow has ever felt quite the right height for you.
Coop Home Goods Eden Bed Pillow Queen Size for ...
The shredded foam in this Xtreme Comforts pillow molds around my head, and the cover feels cool to the touch. I removed some foam to make it thinner. Grab this if you want an adjustable pillow for less.
Xtreme Comforts Shredded Memory Foam Pillow ...
Unlike my old pillows, the Snuggle-Pedic holds its shape all night, and I can fluff it back up in seconds. The shredded foam is adjustable if you want it flatter. Pick this if your current pillow goes flat by morning.
Snuggle-Pedic Shredded Memory Foam Pillow
The contoured shape of this Cushion Lab pillow cradles my neck whether I sleep on my back or side. It feels firm but not hard. Upgrade to this if you switch positions at night and want one pillow that works for both.
C CUSHION LAB Deep Sleep Ergonomic Pillow
Filled with buckwheat hulls, the Hullo pillow holds my head firmly in place and stays cool all night. It makes a soft rustling sound at first. Try this if foam pillows feel too squishy and warm for you.
Hullo Buckwheat Pillow – Standard Size 20x26
The raised edges of this Elviros pillow support my neck while the center dip cradles my head on my back. It took a few nights to get used to. Go for it if you want a contoured foam pillow at a fair price.
Elviros Cervical Memory Foam Pillows
Vaunn's firm memory foam pillow holds its shape, and I use it under my knees on my back or between them on my side. It does not flatten overnight. Pick this if softer leg pillows feel too squishy for you.
Vaunn Medical Memory Foam Pillow for Back, Leg and Hip ...
With the Mediflow I add or remove water to dial in how firm the pillow feels, which no other pillow lets me do. The fiber layer on top keeps it soft. Worth it if you want a pillow you can fine tune exactly.
Mediflow Fiber Original Water Pillow
Between my knees on side-sleeping nights, the Contour Legacy pillow keeps my legs from stacking awkwardly. It holds its shape well. Grab this if you wake up with a regular pillow twisted between your legs.
Contour Legacy Leg & Knee Foam Support Pillow
This memory foam knee pillow molds between my knees, and the strap keeps it in place all night. The cover zips off for washing. Pick it if your knee pillow always ends up on the floor by morning.
Everlasting Comfort Knee Pillow | Side Sleeper Support for ...
I use the Kolbs foam wedge to prop myself up for reading in bed, or slide it under my knees when lying back. It feels firm and stable. Worth it if you read or watch TV in bed a lot.
Kolbs Bed Wedge Pillow for Sleep Apnea
For reading in bed, the InteVision wedge has a firm slope that keeps me propped up comfortably without sliding down. It holds its shape night after night. Go for this if you sit up in bed often and stacked pillows keep collapsing.
InteVision Foam Bed Wedge Pillow (26" x ...
This curved lumbar pillow fills the gap behind my lower back, so I sit up straighter at my desk. It straps onto office chairs and car seats. Grab this if you sit for long stretches and your chair feels flat behind you.
Lumbar Support Back Pillow Office Chair and Car Seat ...
The ComfiLife cushion has a gel layer that feels cooler and a cutout at the back that takes pressure off my tailbone on long workdays. It moves between chairs easily. Pick this if your desk chair feels hard after an hour.
ComfiLife Gel Enhanced Seat Cushion
The adjustable strap holds this lumbar cushion in my car seat or desk chair, so I move it between both. The memory foam keeps its shape. Worth it if you want one lumbar pillow for road trips and office days.
Everlasting Comfort Lumbar Support Cushion | Memory ...
I hug the Coop body pillow as a side sleeper so my top arm and leg have somewhere to rest. The fill is adjustable like their regular pillows. Go for this if you usually stuff a spare pillow between your knees.
Coop Home Goods Original Adjustable Body Pillow 20x54